Why Insurance May Deny Water Damage Claims for Property Owners

Homeowners insurance and broad names insurance (for hotels and Bed and Breakfasts) are essential for safeguarding property owners from unexpected financial burdens. However, despite policies that specifically cover water damage, there are many loopholes insurance companies use to deny common claims. Many property owners are unaware that their insurance policies may not cover all types of water damage. Leaking toilets, in particular, can lead to significant financial headaches, especially when toilet leaks go undetected. Understanding the common reasons for these denials can help property owners take preventative measures and protect their investments.

Common Reasons Water Damage Claims Get Denied

1. Old Pipes

One of the most common reasons for denied water damage claims is the presence of old or deteriorated plumbing. Insurance companies often exclude coverage for damages caused by outdated pipes, as they are considered a known risk. For properties with outdated plumbing valves and antiquated pipes, insurers will argue that the damage was foreseeable and preventable. Therefore, leak detection through regular inspections and timely replacement of aging plumbing are crucial to maintaining coverage and preventing significant damage.

2. Negligent Maintenance Schedules

Insurance policies generally require property owners to maintain their properties adequately. Skipping routine inspections or delaying necessary repairs can lead to denied claims due to negligent maintenance. Insurers expect property owners to take reasonable steps to prevent damage, including regular check-ups on plumbing valves and systems. Failure to adhere to these maintenance schedules can result in the insurance company's refusal to cover the damage, deeming it the property owner’s fault due to neglect.

3. Flood Damage from Internal Sources

While standard property insurance covers flood damage from external sources, such as heavy rainfall or river overflow, it typically does not cover flood damage that originates within the home. For instance, standard coverage excludes water damage caused by a leaking toilet or an internal burst pipe. Proper leak detection is crucial as this exclusion can leave property owners with substantial repair costs since the damage is considered a direct result of internal plumbing failure, not an external flood.

4. Gradual Damage Over Time

Insurance policies cover sudden and accidental damage, not gradual deterioration. Gradual damage, such as a slow leaking toilet or dripping sink, is often excluded from insurance policies. Insurers argue that this damage type is preventable with proper maintenance and timely intervention. Insurers may also argue that this damage is old and possibly pre-existing.

Therefore, property owners must be vigilant with leak detection and address any plumbing issues promptly to avoid costly repairs and potential claim denials.

Preventing Damage and Ensuring Coverage

Avoiding these common pitfalls and ensuring that water damage claims are covered is easier if property owners adopt a proactive approach to property maintenance. Regularly inspecting and maintaining plumbing systems is essential. Preventative maintenance should include checking for leaks, replacing old pipes and plumbing valves, and ensuring that all plumbing fixtures are in good working order. Keeping detailed records of all maintenance activities, repairs, and inspections can also support insurance claims, providing proof that the property owner has taken reasonable steps to prevent damage. 

Guard Dog Valve: A Smart Solution

One effective solution for preventing toilet leaks and water damage related to running toilets is the Guard Dog Valve. This innovative, motion-activated valve automatically shuts off the water supply to the toilet bowl once the user leaves the restroom, preventing continuous water flow and unnoticed leaks. By installing Guard Dog Valves, property owners can significantly reduce the risk of water damage from leaking toilets, ensuring their properties remain in excellent condition and minimizing the likelihood of costly insurance claim denials. This investment not only saves money on potential repairs but also supports sustainable water conservation practices, benefiting both the property owner and the environment.

Understanding why water damage claims may be denied is essential for property owners. By being proactive in maintenance and utilizing solutions like the Guard Dog Valve, property owners can safeguard their homes from unexpected water damage and maximize their insurance coverage claims.

Back to blog